COVID-19 AND MOBILITY: The Burden of Migrant Workers

The 2019 coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has caused a huge disruption in our economy, resulting in one of the largest global recession in recent history. As the global economy is in recession, many migrant workers face job insecurity and unemployment, resulting in lower or lost income. There were an estimated 272 million migrants worldwide in 2019 (1), a particularly vulnerable population during this pandemic due to their substandard living and working conditions. Additionally, discrimination and stigma promote inequality in health, undermine trust in public health professionals, and reduces the opportunity for cohesion with the host community, further increasing their vulnerability (2).  

In addition to migrant workers living and working in troublesome conditions, millions of refugees and migrants are living in camps and detention centres worldwide (3).  Unfortunately, many migrant camps frequently function under inadequate conditions such as insufficient resources for basic hygiene and overcrowding that makes social distancing measures practically impossible. These conditions promote the spread of infectious disease, including COVID-19.

A subgroup within the migrant population, undocumented migrants, are perhaps in greater need than the rest of the migrant population. The numbers and whereabouts of undocumented migrants are not well known for obvious reasons, but they also live under conditions that present a higher risk to their well-being, including no prior bond of trust with local and federal authorities, no established means of communication of health information through the public sector, unsuitable working environments where social distancing measures can't be implemented (1). The health needs of refugees, legal and undocumented migrants, is a delicate topic but one that must be discussed in the midst of our current global emergency. Everyone working on combating the COVID-19 pandemic must not forget the health needs of the migrant population.

Specific attention must be given to the migrant population to prevent them from falling into poverty and to protect them from the psychological, economical, and societal impact of the pandemic. This article aims to understand the impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the migrant population and its family members, specifically within the context of two regions: Asia and the Americas.

COVID-19 and Migrant Workers

 

Migrant workers form a significant part of the workforce in many counties, and COVID-19 exacerbates the difficult situation migrants are already experiencing. Migrants are affected by an added layer of personal, situational, commercial, social and structural factors that make them especially vulnerable to the negative effects of the pandemic (4). Measures introduced in different countries to limit the spread of the virus, such as lockdowns, also affects migration and mobility. These measures impact labour migration (5), and the recruitment of new and returning existing workers (6).

Asia

 

Travel restriction as a control measure has been adopted by more than 220 countries around the globe due to COVID-19 (7).  This has greatly impacted the Asian continent and it affects migrant workers seeking to return to their home countries. Travel restrictions come in the form of closing borders and forcing numerous migrant labourers to return home earlier than anticipated due to countrywide lockdowns. Expelling migrant workers early has had an especially big impact on those with invalid travel documents, who may have to cross international borders by irregular means (7).

When Thailand announced they would temporarily close their borders in March, thousands of jobless migrant workers sought to cross the borders in order to return to their homes. However, those without a proper documentation were unable to, facing several challenges such as job insecurity, reduced income, food insecurity, cultural-linguistic barriers to health information, and limited access to health services. The impacts have also affected their families for whom remittances are their primary source of money. Because of their illegal status, many of them either fall outside or are less likely to access social protection and financial safety nets (8). 

Many undocumented migrant workers are facing a livelihood impact due to the economic downturn and lockdown measures, and these difficulties can influence their mental health status in the form of stress and/or depression. According to the Kepone Free Funeral Service Society, eight undocumented migrants from Myanmar have committed suicide in Malaysia in late May and June after being unemployed for months and fearing arrest amid an immigration crackdown (9). Moreover, there have been reports of stigmatization and discrimination towards migrants stemming from the accusation of spreading the corona virus (10). The COVID-19 pandemic has ruthlessly exacerbated the vulnerability of these marginalized populations. 

Americas

 

The migration situation in the Americas can perhaps best be described as complex, due to the unique circumstances and context of each country and region. For example, in South America, most developed countries’ borders are relatively open for migrants from surrounding countries in the region.  Despite the general acceptance of migrants in the region, discrimination towards this population still remains present (11–14). To counter the discrimination the migrants face in the region, the Global Compact for Migration was endorsed by most countries in Latin America and by the United Nation General Assembly on 19 December 2018, with the aim of contributing to a better positioning of migrants in their countries of destination (15). 

Unfortunately, alongside the pandemic, economic activities were halted, social distancing norms were enforced, and businesses were indefinitely shut-down, increasing the vulnerability of migrants in the region (16). As most migrants work in restaurants, hotels, shops and sectors of the informal economy, many migrants are now jobless and without social benefits coming from the governments due to their immigration status (17). This situation greatly increases their vulnerability to the pandemic as most migrants work for a wage that provides just enough for daily living.

Although in some countries, such as Argentina, both legal and undocumented migrants have access to the country’s public health system, they are not exempt to acts of discrimination (11, 12). Meanwhile, migrants living in countries such as Peru and the United States must face various barriers in order to access the country’s health system, as they frequently do not meet the specific legal requirements to access health services (11).

The COVID-19 pandemic has also had a significant effect on migration mobility in the region, especially for those crossing through Central America and Mexico. Border closures and lock-downs have disrupted the migrant trail that has the final destination in the United States (18).  However, between the months of April and July, the number of migrants arrested along the border have more than doubled compared to previous months (19). 

Some have argued that the increase in the number of detainees may have been influenced by a new US administration policy that returns detained migrants quickly to Mexico (18). This can often happen within hours of their arrest since they are attempting to decrease the number of individuals in US immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention centres, as the conditions of the centres lead to increased risk of exposure to the virus. Ironically, this also presents migrants with a golden opportunity, as it provides them with more chances to illegally cross the border after being detained and then quickly released.

Within the US, however, legal and especially undocumented immigrants face a different challenge.  The pandemic has exposed many weaknesses of the US health system as public health officials encourage people to consult their doctors first before seeking hospital care (20).  Unfortunately, most undocumented immigrants don’t have a primary care provider and are also excluded from the Affordable Care Act.  Therefore, they must rely on their local and already strained emergency department and must incur out-of-pocket expenses for their services. It is also worth noting that due to the lack of financial protection, this population is more at risk of losing their jobs during the pandemic. Extreme poverty is estimated to extend to more than 5 million U.S. American children who have undocumented immigrant parents, adding the fact that they there are unable to receive paid-leave benefits and direct cash transfers for U.S. citizens available from a recent federal economic relief package (21).

The COVID-19 pandemic will most likely affect those with a lower socioeconomic status and more vulnerable populations, making the migrant community an especially vulnerable group. The global pandemic, as its name implies, is a global problem and the international community must advocate more strongly for financial resources that help provide better access to health services for migrants.  If the international community is truly committed to fighting COVID-19 on a global scale, we must also not forget to include the migrant community withing the global health response. 

A Call to Action!

What can we do as young professionals?  

  1. Participate in your local refugee centre or shelter! Many refugee centres and shelters are at times the only known point of access to health services for many traveling migrants and could always use an extra pair of hands from local volunteers, as long as local and social distancing norms are being followed. Other work could also include support in legal work and job searching for unemployed migrants.

  2. Help spread the word! As potential global health influencers, we can help run public information campaigns targeting migrant workers who have cultural-linguistic barriers or spread evidence-based information that help fight discrimination and stigma towards the migrant population.

  3. Help spread information about migrant’s rights and access to social protection benefits in your local countries! In some cases, many migrants are unaware of their rights and possible benefits that they might have in the host country (e.g. access to health services).

By

 

Israel Herrera Ramirez

Editorial officer for CGHI, pharmacist and public health professional. Enjoys working on public health topics through a health systems perspective.

Ei Ei Aung

Ei Ei is the Quality assurance officer at CGHI and enjoys working on implementation research on health and development issues.

References:

1.   McAuliffe M, Khadria B, editors. World Migration Report 2020 [Internet]. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organization for Migration; 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 5]. Available from: https://bit.ly/2R0zhV6

2.   Guadagno L. Migrants and the COVID-19 pandemic: an initial analysis [Internet]. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organization for Migration; 2020 [cited 2020 Oct 4] p. 28. (Migration Research Series). Report No.: 60. Available from: https://bit.ly/3kwnnPO

3.   World Health Organization. Report on the health of refugees and migrants in the WHO European Region: No public health without refugees and migrant health [Internet]. Copenhagen, Denmark: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2018 p. 114. Available from: https://bit.ly/3h3VonS

4.   Institute of Migration. The impact of COVID-19 on migrants [Internet]. Switzerland: IOM UN Migration; (Migration Factsheet). Report No.: 6. Available from: https://bit.ly/3bwywfL

5.   World Bank Group, The Global Knowledge Partnership on Migration and Development. COVID-19: Crisis Through a Migration Lens [Internet]. Washington, D.C., USA: World Bank Group; 2020 Apr p. 50. (Migration and Development Brief). Report No.: 32. Available from: https://bit.ly/2ETJ1OA

6.   Gagnon J. COVID-19: consequences for international migration and development [Internet]. Development Matters. 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 5]. Available from: https://bit.ly/2ZaCQfS

7.   Nanthini S. In Limbo in ASEAN: Pandemic and Irregular Migration. RSIS Comment. 2020 Jun 25;131.

8.   Social Science in Humanitarian Action Platform, Schmidt-Sane M, Ripoll S, Wilkinson A. Key Considerations for COVID-19 Management in Marginalised Populations in Southeast Asia: Transnational Migrants, Informal Workers, and People Living in Informal Settlements - Myanmar [Internet]. SSHAP; 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 5]. Available from: https://bit.ly/3jnSKe9

9.   Htwe ZZ. Without Work and Fearing Arrest, Undocumented Myanmar Migrants in Malaysia Take Their Own Lives. The Irrawaddy [Internet]. 2020 Jun 17 [cited 2020 Sep 5]; Available from: https://bit.ly/2IUZCmu

10. Douglas J, Hulshof K, Motus N, Naciri M, Nishimoto T. End stigma and discrimination against migrant workers and their children during COVID-19 pandemic [Internet]. ReliefWeb. 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 5]. Available from: https://bit.ly/2J6NnUh

11. Segnana J. Situation of migrants in Latin America within the COVID-19 context [Internet]. UNDP in Latin America and the Caribbean. 2020 [cited 2020 Aug 8]. Available from: https://bit.ly/34opwHA

12. Fernández-Bravo E. Characterising migrations in Latin America: Analysis and media coverage proposals of the Argentine case. Global Campus Latin America-Caribbean; p. 15. (Policy Briefs 2019).

13. Castilla C, Nyberg-Sørensen N. Venezuelans flee accelerating collapse: Latin Americas evolving migration criss. Danish Institute for International Studies; 2019 Mar p. 4. (DIIS Policy Brief).

14. Jones T. Xenophobia in Spite of Citizenship: Seasonal Migrant Workers in Brazil. Contracorriente Una Rev Estud Latinoam. 2020;17(2):54–68.

15. International Organization for Migration. The Global Compact for Migration [Internet]. [cited 2020 Aug 8]. Available from: https://bit.ly/3dWoOVq

16. Ortega F, Sosa D. Los inmigrantes y la pandemia de coronavirus: una bomba de tiempo. La Nación [Internet]. 2020 Apr 12 [cited 2020 Aug 8]; Available from: https://bit.ly/3krIz9N

17. United Nations. The Impact of COVID-19 on Latin America and the Caribbean. New York City, United States: United Nations; 2020 Jul.

18. Semple K. After a Lull, the Number of Migrants Trying to Enter the U.S. Has Soared. The New York Times [Internet]. 2020 Aug 6 [cited 2020 Aug 15]; Available from: https://bit.ly/35wpKf3

19. Miroff N. As U.S. expels migrants, they return, again and again, across Mexico border. Washington Post [Internet]. [cited 2020 Aug 15]; Available from: https://wapo.st/34p7Co3

20. Page KR, Venkataramani M, Beyrer C, Polk S. Undocumented U.S. Immigrants and Covid-19. N Engl J Med. 2020 May 21;382(21):e62.

21. The CARES Act Works for All Americans | U.S. Department of the Treasury [Internet]. [cited 2020 Sep 5]. Available from: https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/cares

Previous
Previous

Improving Global Sexual and Reproductive Health

Next
Next

Disinformation and denialism in Serbia